Embark on a delightful culinary journey to discover the most irresistible desserts and sweet treats awaiting you in the vibrant coastal towns of Gulf Shores and Orange Beach, Alabama! From iconic Key Lime Pie to whimsical milkshakes and artisanal doughnuts, this guide unveils a treasure trove of sugary delights guaranteed to satisfy every craving. Prepare to indulge your sweet tooth and explore the best dessert spots that make these Alabama beaches a true paradise for food lovers.
Planning your Gulf Shores & Orange Beach getaway? Here are quick links to enhance your trip:
Find the Best Hotels and Vacation Rentals
Discover Exciting Local Tours and Activities
Indulge Your Sweet Tooth: The Ultimate Guide to Desserts in Gulf Shores & Orange Beach, Alabama
During our extensive explorations of Gulf Shores and Orange Beach, we took on the delightful task of sampling an array of sweet treats. It was a rigorous but undeniably enjoyable mission, ensuring we could bring you a curated list of the absolute best desserts these charming coastal towns have to offer. Our quest spanned everything from fluffy doughnuts and creamy bread puddings to towering milkshakes and zesty pies, all to identify those exceptional sweet experiences you simply cannot miss.
Living in Gulf Shores now allows us even more opportunities to uncover new and exciting dessert havens, continually updating our list with fresh finds. While this guide focuses purely on the sweet side of dining, if you’re planning full meals, be sure to explore our comprehensive Gulf Shores Restaurants guide for an incredible culinary adventure.
Crazy Milkshakes at The Yard Milkshake Bar
Prepare to have your mind blown and your taste buds tantalized at The Yard Milkshake Bar, a phenomenon that has taken Gulf Shores by storm. Famous for its over-the-top, Instagram-worthy mason jar concoctions, The Yard offers an unforgettable dessert experience. Each milkshake is a work of art, designed not just to be eaten but to be marveled at. Imagine a chilled mason jar, lavishly rimmed and overflowing with creamy ice cream, drizzles, and an astonishing array of toppings that often include entire slices of cake, cookies, or even a full cupcake!
The menu is a playground of inventive flavors and fantastical themes. For instance, the **Unicorn** milkshake is a cotton candy dream, featuring vibrant blue and pink marshmallow drizzles, a rainbow sprinkle-dipped rim, and crowned with a sugar cone unicorn horn, rainbow whipped cream, and fluffy cotton candy clouds. It’s a whimsical masterpiece that delights both the eyes and the palate.
Chocolate lovers will gravitate towards the **Cookie Dough Delicious**, a rich symphony of cookie dough ice cream, chocolate drizzle, a chocolate-chip-rolled jar, and a generous scoop of edible chocolate chip cookie dough, all finished with whipped cream. For those who appreciate a classic twist, the **Old School Banana Split** reimagines the timeless favorite with strawberry and banana pudding ice cream, chocolate and strawberry drizzles, a peanut-rolled jar, and topped with a banana, whipped cream, and of course, a cherry.
Another showstopper is **The Mermaid**, a magical blend of blue monster and cake batter ice cream with pink marshmallow cream drizzle, a teal marshmallow cream-dipped jar adorned with mermaid candy jewels, and finished with a delicate white chocolate mermaid tail and a rock candy stick. While the crazy shakes are a main draw, The Yard also offers simpler single-cup ice cream and regular shakes for those seeking a less extravagant, but equally delicious, treat. You can even customize your own edible cookie dough creation in a waffle cone. Be aware that this popular spot often has a line, especially during peak seasons, but the wait is undoubtedly worth every sweet, decadent spoonful.
Address: 3800 Gulf Shores Pkwy #218, Gulf Shores, AL 36542
Phone: (251) 948-0121
Key Lime Pie at LuLu’s
LuLu’s isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a Gulf Shores institution, beloved for its lively atmosphere, fantastic food, and a commitment to inclusivity. While their menu boasts an array of Gulf Coast favorites, it’s their Key Lime Pie that stands out as an iconic dessert, a must-try for any visitor. This isn’t just any pie; it’s a perfectly balanced creation that captures the essence of coastal sweetness – a tangy, creamy filling nestled in a perfectly baked crust, offering a refreshing end to any meal.
What makes LuLu’s even more commendable is their dedication to accommodating all diners. They thoughtfully provide multiple allergy menus, ensuring that guests with dietary restrictions, whether gluten, soy, or other common allergens, can dine with confidence and enjoyment. Simply ask your server for their special allergy menus to navigate your choices effortlessly. The Key Lime Pie is a testament to their culinary excellence, consistently delivering that delightful zing and smooth texture that keeps patrons coming back.
Beyond savoring this delectable pie, be sure to explore the Gulf Shores & Orange Beach visitor bureau’s Key Lime Pie Trail, a fun way to sample various interpretations of this beloved dessert across the region. LuLu’s Key Lime Pie is a definitive highlight on this trail, making it an essential stop on your sweet treat adventure.
Address: 200 E 25th Ave, Gulf Shores, AL 36542
Phone: (251) 967-5858
Lickin Good Donuts
For those who believe that a good day starts with a great doughnut, Lickin Good Donuts in Gulf Shores is an absolute must-visit. This charming shop specializes in crafting not only incredibly delicious but also adorably creative doughnuts that are a feast for both the eyes and the palate. Each pastry is made with care, resulting in a perfect balance of fluffy texture and vibrant flavor.
During our visit, we were particularly captivated by the unique mermaid donut, a whimsical creation we hadn’t encountered before. But the charm doesn’t stop there; the playful minion and Elmo donuts were equally delightful, proving that whether you’re a child or just young at heart, there’s a character-themed treat to bring a smile to your face. In truth, every single donut we sampled was amazing, a testament to the quality and artistry found at Lickin Good Donuts. It’s the ideal spot to grab a breakfast treat or an afternoon pick-me-up that adds a sprinkle of joy to your Gulf Shores vacation.
To explore more fantastic options, don’t miss our comprehensive guide to the best doughnuts in Gulf Shores and Orange Beach.
Address: 229 E 20th Ave #14, Gulf Shores, AL 36542
Phone: (251) 233-3968
Java Chip Frappe at Southern Grind Coffee House
When the coastal Alabama heat calls for a refreshing treat, or you simply crave an exceptional coffee experience, Southern Grind Coffee House is your destination in Orange Beach. This beloved local gem offers more than just coffee; it’s a cozy haven where you can unwind and indulge. Their Java Chip Frappe is a standout – a perfectly blended, icy concoction that combines rich coffee flavor with decadent chocolate chips, all whipped to frosty perfection. It’s the ideal antidote to a warm day, offering both a caffeine kick and a sweet escape.
Beyond the frappes, Southern Grind boasts an impressive array of baked goods that are crafted with the same attention to quality. We particularly fell in love with their salted caramel cookies – so good, in fact, that we instantly regretted not buying a dozen to take home! These cookies strike a masterful balance between sweet and salty, with a chewy texture that is utterly addictive. The inviting ambiance, coupled with their excellent coffee and irresistible pastries, makes Southern Grind Coffee House a perfect stop for breakfast, a midday pick-me-up, or a relaxing afternoon treat.
Address at The Wharf: 4751 Main St #116, Orange Beach, AL 36561
Phone: (251) 923-3265
Address at INDIGO: 22843 Perdido Beach Blvd, Orange Beach, AL 36561
Phone: (251) 975-2883
Mason Jar Sundaes at Island Ice Cream and Treats
Nestled near West Beach, Island Ice Cream and Treats is a vibrant destination for anyone seeking epic ice cream creations that truly satisfy a sweet tooth. What makes this spot even more exciting is its connection to The Yard Milkshake Bar, a venture that gained global recognition after its appearance on Shark Tank. The owner of Island Ice Cream has channeled that same innovative spirit into crafting incredible Mason Jar Sundaes that are both visually stunning and incredibly delicious.
Each sundae is a meticulously designed masterpiece, packed with generous scoops of ice cream and an imaginative assortment of toppings. Take, for instance, the **Mint Green Grasshopper Sundae**, a refreshing delight featuring mint chip ice cream, rich chocolate fudge, whipped cream, crushed Oreos, and a cherry – a perfect balance of cool mint and deep chocolate. The **Peanut Butter Sundae** is a dream for nut butter enthusiasts, with creamy vanilla ice cream, warm melted peanut butter, Reese’s Pieces, whipped cream, and a cherry. For a campfire-inspired treat, the **Smores Sundae** brings together chocolate ice cream, mini marshmallows, graham crackers, chocolate fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry.
Beyond traditional sundaes, Island Ice Cream and Treats also offers unique creations like the **Beach Hair Doughnut Care**, a cinnamon sugar ice cream base in a chocolate-iced jar dipped in graham crackers, topped with a fluffy doughnut, whipped cream, and chocolate syrup. The **Cookie Crunch** is a textural delight with cookie two-step ice cream in a vanilla-iced jar rolled in chocolate chips, crowned with a chocolate chip cookie, whipped cream, and chocolate drizzle. Finally, the **Coco Loco** transports you to a tropical paradise with coconut ice cream in a chocolate-iced jar dipped in coconut flakes, lavishly topped with coconut cake, whipped cream, and chocolate drizzle. These sundaes are not just desserts; they are an experience, making Island Ice Cream and Treats a must-visit for families and dessert aficionados alike.
Key Lime Tart at Coast Restaurant at The Beach Club
For those who appreciate a more refined take on the beloved key lime flavor, the Key Lime Tart at Coast Restaurant, located within The Beach Club, is an absolute revelation. This sophisticated dessert offers a delightful counterpoint to the more rustic versions of key lime pie found elsewhere. Here, the tart’s vibrant citrus notes are not overwhelmingly sharp but rather beautifully balanced with a perfectly crumbly, buttery crust. It’s a harmonious blend that creates an elegant and utterly satisfying taste experience.
The presentation is as exquisite as the taste, making it a perfect finale to an upscale dining experience at Coast. While it’s generously sized and easily shareable, we completely understand if you find yourself wanting to savor every single bite on your own – and rest assured, we won’t judge! Diving headfirst into this key lime goodness is a perfectly acceptable response to its undeniable deliciousness. Coast Restaurant offers a picturesque setting with stunning views, elevating the simple pleasure of a dessert into a memorable part of your Gulf Shores vacation.
Address: 925 Beach Club Trail, Gulf Shores, AL 36542
Phone: (888) 224-7684
Twister Cones from Yumm Twister and Ice Cream
Stepping into Yumm Twister and Ice Cream in Gulf Shores is like discovering a little piece of Europe on the Alabama coast. This unique establishment specializes in chimney cones (or trdelník, as they are known in Central Europe), a type of roasted pastry dough that’s spiraled and then filled with incredible gelato and toppings. It’s an experience that stands out from the typical ice cream shop, offering a delightful blend of novelty and exquisite flavor.
The giant chimney cones are available in a variety of epic flavors, providing a warm, slightly crispy, and sweet vessel for their creamy gelato. But Yumm Twister also excels in crafting exceptional milkshakes, each a decadent blend of their high-quality gelato and carefully chosen ingredients. For instance, the **Salted Caramel Pretzel Milkshake** is a masterful combination of vanilla and caramel gelato, milk, crunchy pretzels, whipped cream, and a generous drizzle of caramel sauce – a perfect sweet and salty symphony.
The **Strawberry Shortcake Milkshake** offers a taste of classic Americana with a twist, blending vanilla and strawberry gelato, milk, tender pound cake pieces, fresh strawberries, whipped cream, and a vibrant strawberry sauce. And for cheesecake aficionados, the **Oreo Cheesecake Milkshake** is an absolute dream, featuring vanilla and cookies & cream gelato, milk, creamy cream cheese, crushed Oreo pieces, whipped cream, and a rich chocolate syrup. Located just a few blocks off Gulf Shores Parkway, Yumm Twister and Ice Cream is a delightful detour for an unforgettable dessert that transports your taste buds.
Address – 229 E 20th Ave Suite 8, Gulf Shores, Al, 36542, USA
Phone – 251-281-8288
Brick & Spoon Beignets
Transport your taste buds straight to the heart of New Orleans with the heavenly beignets at Brick & Spoon in Orange Beach. These aren’t just any doughnuts; they are glorious, fluffy pillows of fried dough, generously coated in a snowstorm of powdered sugar. Every bite is a warm, sweet explosion that is utterly worth the delightful mess it inevitably makes on your shirt! It’s an iconic Southern treat that perfectly encapsulates comfort and indulgence.
While the beignets are a phenomenal reason to visit, Brick & Spoon is also renowned for its amazing breakfast and lunch menu, offering a robust selection of savory dishes that perfectly complement their sweet offerings. You can balance out all that wonderful sugar with a hearty meal, ensuring a well-rounded dining experience. Their coffee, too, is delicious and serves as the perfect companion to their sweet pastries. Don’t forget to try another one of their unique sweet delights: the “Bananas in Pajamas,” a dish that lives up to its playful name with rich, sweet flavors. Brick & Spoon provides a vibrant and welcoming atmosphere, making it an excellent spot for a leisurely breakfast or brunch where you can truly indulge.
Address: 24705 Canal Rd, Orange Beach, AL 36561
Phone: (251) 981-7772
Homemade Pop-Tarts at BuzzCatz Coffee & Sweets
BuzzCatz Coffee & Sweets in Orange Beach is a delightful haven for anyone with a love for artisanal pastries and a great cup of coffee. The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a dazzling display in their pastry case, filled with so many amazing choices that picking just one thing can be a wonderfully difficult decision. This charming local spot has mastered the art of creating comforting classics with a gourmet touch.
Among their many irresistible offerings, the homemade Pop-Tarts are a true revelation. Far superior to their store-bought counterparts, these pastries boast flaky crusts and delicious fillings, often adorned with charming toppings like chocolate chips, making them an elevated nostalgic treat. We were completely smitten with them, along with their equally fantastic cookies. BuzzCatz is the quintessential spot to kickstart your day, whether you’re looking for a hearty breakfast sandwich, a perfectly brewed coffee, or a sweet indulgence to brighten your morning. And while you’re there, be sure to cast an admiring glance, or better yet, grab one of their incredible cinnamon rolls – they’re legendary for a reason!
Address: 25689 Canal Rd, Orange Beach, AL 36561
Phone: (251) 980-2899
Key Lime Donut at City Donuts
It’s no secret that the zesty, refreshing flavor of key lime holds a special place in our hearts, and the Key Lime Donut at City Donuts in Orange Beach truly exemplifies why. These donuts are exceptionally good, boasting a perfect blend of sweet and tart that is utterly addictive. We’re talking about a level of deliciousness that would inspire us to wake up at the crack of dawn just to ensure we get our hands on one (or perhaps two!).
City Donuts is a local favorite, and its popularity is a testament to the quality and freshness of its offerings. During the busy tourist season, heed our advice: arrive early! It’s not uncommon for their most sought-after donuts to be completely sold out by 9 AM, a clear indicator of just how beloved they are. Beyond their signature Key Lime Donut, City Donuts offers a wide array of other tempting treats, including savory donut sliders, creamy milkshakes, classic ice cream, and much more. It’s a vibrant and bustling spot that promises a sweet start to any day in Orange Beach.
Address: 26651 Perdido Beach Blvd, Orange Beach, AL 36561
Phone: (251) 981-3688
Big Tickle Milkshake – Sunliner Diner
Step back in time to a classic 1950s diner experience at Sunliner Diner in Gulf Shores, where the milkshake menu is not just dangerous, but an invitation to an “ice cream coma of delicious goodness”! This vibrant, retro-themed eatery offers an experience that’s as fun and nostalgic as its delectable desserts. While all their shakes are superb, the “Big Tickle Party Shake” is a true adventure for the palate.
The **Big Tickle Party Shake** is designed for the adventurous dessert enthusiast. The concept is simple yet exciting: you choose your base ice cream flavor – chocolate, strawberry, or vanilla – and then, you “leave the rest up to us!” This element of surprise is part of the charm, as the culinary team at Sunliner Diner dazzles and delights with their creative toppings and presentation. During our visit, we opted for a vanilla milkshake, which arrived as a festive explosion of Mardi Gras sprinkles, a perfectly crisp waffle, and a bright red cherry, transforming a simple shake into a celebratory treat. The result is always a unique, overflowing masterpiece that embodies the playful spirit of the diner. It’s more than just a milkshake; it’s a full-on party in a glass, making Sunliner Diner a must-visit for families and anyone looking for a fun, sweet escape.
Address: 100 E 2nd Ave, Gulf Shores, AL 36542
Phone: (251) 937-6590
Shave Ice from Frost Bites Food Truck
After a blissful day soaking up the sun and splashing in the waves at the beach, there’s nothing quite like a refreshing treat to cool you down. Head over to the Frost Bites Food Truck, conveniently located at The Beach Club, for an exquisite shave ice experience. This vibrant food truck offers an impressive array of shaved ice flavors, allowing you to customize your perfect frosty concoction. Whether you prefer classic fruit flavors or adventurous combinations, there’s a taste sensation waiting to be discovered.
The beauty of this location is that Frost Bites is part of a cluster of food trucks, meaning you can also find delicious barbecue, savory sandwiches, and a variety of beverages in the same area. This makes it a perfect stop for a casual meal or snack for the whole family. Importantly, you don’t need to be a guest staying at The Beach Club to enjoy these culinary delights. The food trucks are situated just before the security shack, with ample parking available nearby, making them easily accessible to everyone. With picnic tables and a spacious lawn area, it’s an ideal spot to relax, enjoy your shave ice, and unwind after a fun-filled day by the Gulf.
Address: 925 Beach Club Trail, Gulf Shores, AL 36542
Phone: (888) 224-7684
Cafe Beignet – Gulf Shores & Orange Beach
For an authentic taste of New Orleans right on the Alabama Gulf Coast, Cafe Beignet is an essential stop. With convenient locations in both Gulf Shores and Orange Beach, you’re never too far from indulging in their freshly made-to-order beignets. These delightful square doughnuts are fried to a golden perfection and generously dusted with a mountain of powdered sugar, creating a light, airy texture and a sweet, comforting flavor that is simply irresistible.
Standard orders typically come in servings of three or a dozen, making them perfect for a personal treat or to share with family and friends. For those who enjoy a little extra indulgence, Cafe Beignet offers the option to have your beignets filled with creamy vanilla pudding and topped with a luscious chocolate syrup – an extra layer of decadence that takes this classic treat to a new level. The ability to get these amazing pastries at multiple spots means you can satisfy your craving whether you’re exploring Orange Beach or enjoying the sights of Gulf Shores near Rouses Grocery. Cafe Beignet delivers a consistently delicious experience, bringing a beloved Southern tradition to the heart of Alabama’s beaches.
Address – 25405 Perdido Beach Boulevard, Ste. 22, Orange Beach, AL 36561
There is also a Café Beignet Gulf Shores near Rouses Grocery.
Phone – 251-981-2711
Caramel Cake at Deep South Cake Company
If there’s one dessert that truly captures the rich, comforting essence of Southern baking in Orange Beach, it’s the legendary Caramel Cake from Deep South Cake Company. This cake is not merely a dessert; it’s a culinary masterpiece that evokes a sense of nostalgia and pure indulgence. We can confidently say that this decadent cake is utterly drool-worthy and easily one of the best we’ve had in a long, long time, primarily due to its absolutely epic caramel icing.
The Deep South Cake Company prides itself on crafting exquisite, handcrafted cakes and cupcakes for every occasion. Their caramel cake, with its moist layers and luscious, buttery caramel frosting, is a standout, but their extensive menu offers a delightful variety to satisfy any preference. Beyond the celebrated caramel, you can also explore:
- Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting: A classic favorite, rich with spices and topped with a tangy, smooth cream cheese icing.
- Oreo Cake: A chocolate lover’s dream, infused with the beloved cookie.
- Birthday Cake: The quintessential celebratory cake, perfect for any joyous occasion.
- Red Velvet with Decadent Cream Cheese Icing: A vibrant, tender cake paired with a luxurious frosting.
- Vanilla Cake with Chocolate Icing: A timeless combination, simple yet perfectly executed.
- Strawberry Cake: Bursting with fresh fruit flavor, a delightful treat.
- Lemon Cake: Zesty and refreshing, offering a bright citrusy lift.
- Wedding Cake (White Almond): Elegant and subtly flavored, ideal for special moments.
- German Chocolate Cake: A rich chocolate cake with a signature coconut-pecan frosting.
- Peanut Butter Cake: A creamy, nutty delight for peanut butter aficionados.
Deep South Cake Company is more than just a bakery; it’s a testament to the art of baking, offering a slice of Southern comfort in every bite. Whether you’re craving a grand cake for a celebration or a simple cupcake to brighten your day, this is a destination for true dessert lovers.
Address – 25405 Perdido Beach Blvd, Orange Beach, Al
Phone – 251-978-3100
Exploring Beyond Desserts: Your Alabama Gulf Coast Adventure
While the sweet treats of Gulf Shores and Orange Beach are undeniably captivating, these vibrant coastal destinations offer a wealth of experiences for every traveler. Once you’ve satisfied your dessert cravings, embark on further adventures to fully immerse yourself in the charm and beauty of Alabama’s Gulf Coast.
Discover a wide array of activities and attractions for the whole family with our guide to Things to Do In Gulf Shores Alabama. From thrilling outdoor activities to relaxing beach days, there’s something for everyone.
For those planning their main meals, beyond the sweet stops, be sure to explore these fantastic Gulf Shores Restaurants that promise incredible dining experiences, from fresh seafood to casual family eateries.
Experience the magic of the Gulf waters by embarking on a memorable Dolphin Cruise Gulf Shores, where you can witness these magnificent creatures in their natural habitat.
Nature lovers and campers will appreciate the serene beauty and excellent facilities at the Gulf State Park Campground, offering a perfect blend of outdoor adventure and relaxation.
Expand your exploration to the wider state by checking out the incredible natural wonders and historical sites within the Alabama National Parks system.
For more comprehensive information on planning your ultimate beach vacation, including local events, attractions, and accommodations, visit the official Visit Alabama Beaches website. Your unforgettable Gulf Shores and Orange Beach adventure awaits!