Classic Pimento Cheese Recipe: Your Guide to Southern Comfort

Delight in the quintessential taste of the South with this incredibly easy Pimento Cheese recipe! A true Southern classic, this creamy, savory spread is perfect for slathering on crackers, dipping fresh vegetables, or crafting the ultimate pimento cheese sandwich. Get ready to elevate your snack game with a homemade version that’s far superior to any store-bought alternative.

Exploring the World of Pimento Cheese: A Southern Culinary Journey

Our recent adventure through Columbia, South Carolina, offered a deep dive into the diverse and delicious world of pimento cheese, thanks to the Experience Columbia, SC Pimento Cheese Passport. This unforgettable weekend getaway was brimming with exceptional dining experiences, craft cocktails, and the serene beauty of Congaree National Park, all while celebrating the beloved “Southern caviar.”

The Pimento Cheese Passport proved to be an invaluable guide, leading us to five distinct establishments, each renowned for their unique take on pimento cheese. While we only scratched the surface this trip, the passport reveals a vast array of pimento cheese creations waiting to be discovered across Columbia.

Our Pimento Cheese Passport Highlights:

• Bourbon: Our culinary journey began at Bourbon, where we savored their Creole Pimento Cheese – a bold and flavorful rendition – alongside a comforting Pimento Mac and Cheese. Both dishes were truly exquisite, inspiring us to develop our own homemade Pimento Cheese Mac and Cheese recipe to share with you soon.
• Rambo’s Fat Cat Biscuits: Next, we visited Rambo’s Fat Cat Biscuits, a charming spot famous for its Chipotle pimento cheese and sausage biscuit sandwich. Their Congaree Milling Co. Blue Corn Grits, generously topped with pimento cheese, were another standout. We were so captivated by these grits that we’re ordering them online to recreate this incredible dish at home. The restaurant’s adorable orange cat logo was an instant favorite, prompting a sticker purchase as a memento!
• Spotted Salamander Cafe: A highlight of our trip was undoubtedly the Spotted Salamander Cafe. While their menu offered a delightful array of dishes, their special “pimento-less cheese” spread completely won us over. It was a testament to their culinary creativity, proving that a cheese spread could be equally captivating even without the traditional pimentos. This gem quickly became one of our top recommendations for Columbia, SC, restaurants.
• The War Mouth: At The War Mouth, we discovered innovative pimento cheese applications, including Pimento Cheese Yukon Potatoes and an appetizer spread served with unique fried saltines. We had never encountered fried saltines before our visit to Columbia, SC, and they offered a surprisingly delicious crunchy counterpoint to the creamy cheese. This has us wondering if an air fryer version could be replicated at home!
• DiPrato’s Delicatessen: Our final stop on this particular passport adventure was DiPrato’s Delicatessen, a true haven for pimento cheese enthusiasts. They boast multiple varieties, including an enticing gouda pimento cheese with bacon that we’re eager to try making ourselves. Their classic pimento cheese, served with crispy pita chips, was simply irresistible.

Even after these incredible experiences, Columbia’s Pimento Cheese Passport still beckons! We’re already planning our return to sample the pimento cheeseburger pizza at Terra, the classic Pimento Cheese sandwich at the Sandwich Depot, Pimento Cheese Fries at Midwood Smokehouse, and the Low Country Hashbrowns topped with pimento cheese at Cafe Strudel Lexington. These are just a few more highlights from the extensive list of establishments celebrating this beloved Southern staple.

Columbia, South Carolina, truly captured our hearts. For more details on our trip, including our stay at the absolutely gorgeous and uniquely themed Hotel Trundle (complete with a unicorn theme!), be sure to check out John’s Columbia, SC Trip Report on Park Ranger John. We wholeheartedly recommend Hotel Trundle for anyone visiting the area.

What Does Authentic Pimento Cheese Taste Like?

Imagine a symphony of rich, tangy, and slightly peppery flavors, all encased in a velvety smooth and delightfully creamy texture. That’s the magic of pimento cheese. The exact taste can vary based on the specific cheeses used and any additional ingredients, but generally, it’s a harmonious blend.

Our classic recipe offers a wonderfully peppery undertone without being overly spicy, allowing the creamy base and the sweet notes of the pimentos to shine. The luxurious creaminess ensures it spreads effortlessly onto crackers, fresh vegetables, or sandwiches, delivering a burst of authentic Southern flavor with every bite.

Crafting the Perfect Homemade Pimento Cheese: Essential Ingredients

Making homemade pimento cheese dip and spread is surprisingly simple, requiring just a few key ingredients to achieve that classic Southern taste. Below is a quick overview of what you’ll need; precise measurements and step-by-step instructions are provided in the full recipe card at the end of this article.

Core Ingredients for the Best Pimento Cheese:

• Extra Sharp White Cheddar: Provides a robust, tangy backbone to the spread.
• Sharp Cheddar Cheese: Balances the extra sharp cheddar with its familiar, savory notes. Using a blend of cheeses adds depth and complexity to the flavor profile.
• Duke’s Mayonnaise: The secret weapon for authentic Southern pimento cheese.
• Cream Cheese: Adds an irresistible creaminess and helps bind all the ingredients together for a wonderfully spreadable texture.
• Diced Pimentos: These sweet, mild red peppers are essential for both flavor and that iconic orange hue.

The Importance of Quality Ingredients:

• Choosing Your Cheese: While we prefer a mix of sharp cheddar cheeses for a rich flavor, you can certainly use just extra-sharp cheddar or your personal favorite. The crucial tip here is to always buy cheese in a block and grate it yourself at home. Pre-shredded cheeses often contain anti-caking agents that can alter the texture of your pimento cheese, preventing it from becoming as creamy and cohesive as desired. Freshly grated cheese melts beautifully into the spread, contributing to its superior texture.
• The Mayonnaise Debate: For true Southerners, there is simply no debate: Duke’s Mayonnaise is the only acceptable choice for authentic pimento cheese. Its distinctive tangy, slightly less sweet flavor and thick consistency are paramount to achieving the classic taste. If Duke’s isn’t readily available in your area (as it wasn’t for us before moving South), a high-quality, full-fat mayonnaise can be substituted, but be prepared for a slightly different flavor profile.
• Sourcing Pimento Peppers: Diced pimento peppers are usually found in jars near pickles and relish at most grocery stores. They are sweet, mild, and provide the signature color and a subtle fruity note to the cheese spread.

Essential Equipment for Pimento Cheese:

• Cheese Grater: Indispensable for freshly grating your cheese. A food processor with a grating attachment can also save time.
• Large Mixing Bowl: To comfortably combine all your ingredients.
• Hand Mixer / Electric Mixer: For achieving the desired creaminess, especially with the mayonnaise and cream cheese. A sturdy spatula can also work for hand mixing.
• Spatula: For scraping down the bowl and ensuring all ingredients are well incorporated.
• Serving Dish: For presenting your delicious pimento cheese.
• Storage Container with a Lid: For keeping leftovers fresh in the refrigerator.
• Measuring Cups: For accurate ingredient proportions.

How to Make the Best Pimento Cheese: A Simple Guide

Creating this delicious pimento cheese is incredibly straightforward. While complete, detailed instructions are in the printable recipe card below, here’s a quick overview to get you started on your path to Southern comfort:

Step-by-Step Preparation:

1. Grate Your Cheese: Begin by freshly grating your sharp and extra-sharp cheddar cheeses. Set them aside while you prepare the creamy base. This step is crucial for the best texture!

2. Create the Creamy Base: In a large mixing bowl, combine the mayonnaise, softened cream cheese, and diced pimento peppers. Stir by hand with a spatula or use a hand mixer on low speed until the mixture is smooth and evenly combined. Aim for your desired level of creaminess; longer mixing will result in a silkier texture.

3. Combine with Cheese: Gently fold in the freshly shredded cheddar cheese into the creamy base. Mix until just combined. Overmixing at this stage can break down the cheese too much. The goal is to have distinct shreds of cheese throughout the spread. You won’t believe how easy it is to achieve such incredible flavor!

4. Chill and Serve: Transfer your homemade pimento cheese to an airtight container and refrigerate it for at least an hour, or ideally, several hours to allow the flavors to meld and deepen. This chilling period is essential for the best taste and texture.

Preparation and Storage Guidelines:

• Make Ahead: Pimento cheese is a fantastic make-ahead appetizer! Its flavors develop even further when allowed to chill overnight in the refrigerator. Store it in an airtight container until you’re ready to serve.
• Storage: Always store pimento cheese in an airtight container in the refrigerator. It typically stays fresh for up to 5-7 days.
• Freezing Pimento Cheese: While technically possible to freeze pimento cheese for up to three months, be aware that the texture may change upon thawing. The mayonnaise and cream cheese can sometimes separate, resulting in a less smooth consistency. It’s best enjoyed fresh or simply refrigerated.

Recipe Variations and Customization:

This classic Southern pimento cheese recipe serves as a perfect foundation, easily adaptable to suit your personal taste preferences. Feel free to experiment with these delicious additions and substitutions:

• Spice It Up: For a kick, add a dash of hot sauce (like Tabasco or a Louisiana-style hot sauce), a pinch of cayenne pepper, or finely diced jalapeños.
• Aromatic Boost: Incorporate garlic powder, onion powder, a touch of Worcestershire sauce, or even fresh chives or finely diced green onions for added depth.
• Tangy Twists: A splash of pickle juice can introduce a subtle tang, while green olives (finely chopped) offer a briny counterpoint.
• Smoky Notes: Crispy bacon bits or a hint of smoked paprika can add a wonderful smoky dimension.
• Cheese Blends: Beyond cheddar, consider adding a small amount of Monterey Jack, Colby, or even smoked Gouda for a unique flavor profile. Remember to grate these yourself too!

We’ve intentionally kept this base pimento cheese spread recipe straightforward, encouraging you to personalize it with your favorite flavors. The combination of both mayonnaise and cream cheese in our recipe ensures an incredibly creamy texture that holds together beautifully and spreads effortlessly on crackers and sandwiches. Some traditional recipes omit cream cheese, but we find it greatly enhances the overall consistency and richness.

• Vegetarian Option: This recipe is naturally vegetarian, making it a crowd-pleaser for many.
• Vegan Option: While we haven’t personally tested it, you could experiment with vegan mayonnaise and plant-based cheddar and cream cheese alternatives to create a vegan version.
• Gluten-Free: This recipe is naturally gluten-free, provided your ingredients (especially mayonnaise) do not contain hidden gluten.
• Adjusting Serving Size: The current recipe yields approximately 16 ounces of pimento cheese dip, perfect for 8 servings. You can easily adjust the serving size in the recipe card below to half or even double or triple it for larger gatherings and events.

Tips for Achieving the Best Pimento Cheese:

• Room Temperature Ingredients: Ensure your cream cheese and mayonnaise are at room temperature. This makes them much easier to combine smoothly, preventing lumps and ensuring a consistently creamy spread.
• Freshly Grated Cheese is Key: As mentioned, avoid pre-shredded cheese. Grating your own ensures the best texture and flavor.
• Don’t Rush the Chill: While tempting to dive in immediately, allowing the pimento cheese to chill for at least an hour (or longer) gives the flavors time to meld and intensify, resulting in a much more delicious spread.
• Taste and Adjust: Before serving, always taste your pimento cheese and adjust seasonings as needed. A pinch of salt, a crack of black pepper, or a bit more cayenne can make all the difference.

It’s worth noting that “Pimento Cheese” and “Pimiento Cheese” are interchangeable spellings, so don’t be surprised to see both! The nutrition information, including calories, protein, carbohydrates, fat, and more, will vary based on the specific brands and products you use.

What to Serve with Pimento Cheese: Endless Possibilities

Pimento cheese is incredibly versatile and pairs wonderfully with a wide array of sides, main dishes, and even drinks. Here are some suggestions to inspire your next meal or gathering:

Classic Dippers:

• A variety of crackers (Ritz, Club, artisan crackers, saltines, wheat crackers)
• Fresh vegetables (celery sticks, carrot sticks, cucumber slices, red bell pepper strips, cherry tomatoes)
• Pretzels, pita chips, bagel chips, sliced baguettes, or corn chips

Hearty Sides:

• Southern Fried Cabbage
• BLT Pasta Salad
• Air Fryer Baked Potato
• Cheesy Ranch Potatoes
• Cheesy Hashbrowns
• Stuffed Peppers

Main Dishes (as a topping or ingredient):

• Grilled cheese sandwiches (the ultimate comfort food!)
• Burgers or hot dogs
• Scooped onto baked potatoes or grits
• Mixed into a creamy pasta dish or mac and cheese
• Spread into quesadillas
• Slow Cooker Gumbo
• Chicken and Dumplings

Delightful Desserts (to balance the savory):

• Ooey Gooey Butter Cake
• Dreamsicle Salad
• Bisquick Peach Cobbler
• Banana Pudding Poke Cake
• Nutter Butter Banana Pudding

Refreshing Drinks:

• Lemonade
• Sweet Tea
• Watermelon Aqua Fresca
• Brazilian Lemonade
• Passion Tea Lemonade
• Frosted Lemonade

When to Serve Pimento Cheese:

This delightful Southern spread is perfect for almost any occasion! Its versatility makes it suitable for:

• Picnics and outdoor gatherings
• Game day parties (especially football parties!)
• As a versatile appetizer for holiday parties or casual get-togethers
• A satisfying afternoon snack for the family
• Any day you’re craving a delicious, cheesy dip!

Explore More Great Recipe Collections:

If you love discovering new and easy recipes, be sure to check out our other popular collections:

3-Ingredient Recipes: Simple yet delicious recipes for appetizers, entrees, and desserts that require minimal ingredients.

Bacon Recipes: From breakfast to dinner and everything in between, explore our favorite recipes featuring savory bacon.

Easy Bisquick Recipes: Discover a variety of recipes made with simple Bisquick, perfect for quick breakfasts, snacks, and comforting meals.

Easy Dip Recipes: Find the perfect savory or sweet dip for your next Super Bowl party, holiday gathering, or casual snack time.

Ground Beef Crockpot Recipes: Effortless ground beef recipes ideal for family dinners, potlucks, and any occasion.

Potluck Recipes: Great ideas for feeding a crowd at work parties, holiday events, or church picnics.

For even more culinary inspiration, browse our extensive collection of copycat recipes, delectable dessert recipes, and convenient CrockPot Recipes.

Stay connected and never miss a recipe by following Tammilee Tips on MSN, Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest!