Nestled in the heart of Oklahoma, Stillwater might surprise you with its incredibly vibrant and diverse food scene. My recent visit unveiled a culinary landscape far richer than I had anticipated, brimming with charming local eateries, innovative menus, and a unique, welcoming atmosphere that makes every meal an experience. There are so many fantastic restaurants to explore in Stillwater, Oklahoma, that I truly believe a single trip isn’t enough to savor them all. Beyond the delicious flavors, I was also captivated by Stillwater Restaurants’ distinctive t-shirt culture – a local tradition that adds an extra layer of character to this charming college town.
Short on time but craving a taste of Stillwater? Here are my top recommendations for dining and more:
🏨Book Your Stay in Stillwater
📍Explore Stillwater Tours & Activities
Discovering Stillwater’s Best Restaurants: A Culinary Journey
The culinary landscape of Stillwater, Oklahoma, is more than just a collection of eateries; it’s a vibrant community hub where food, history, and local pride intertwine. What truly sets Stillwater apart, besides its fantastic cuisine, is the widespread t-shirt culture among its restaurants. This unique phenomenon, arguably sparked by the iconic success of Eskimo Joe’s merchandise, has transformed into a city-wide tradition. Nearly every restaurant proudly features its own line of t-shirts for sale, each with unique designs that are often quite amazing. When I first arrived, I never imagined I’d be significantly increasing my luggage weight with so many cool tees! While some extra clothes were acquired due to unexpected flight delays, the majority were irresistible souvenirs from Stillwater’s excellent dining establishments.
This article serves as a comprehensive guide to some of the must-visit restaurants in Stillwater, Oklahoma, based on my unforgettable experiences. I consider this just the first installment of my culinary explorations, as I spotted countless other promising establishments that looked absolutely fantastic and deserve a return visit. Prepare to embark on a delicious journey through Stillwater’s finest, where every dish tells a story and every visit leaves a lasting impression.
Eskimo Joe’s: A Stillwater Institution Since 1975
Celebrating over four decades of service, Eskimo Joe’s isn’t just a restaurant; it’s a bona fide landmark and a quintessential Stillwater experience. Founded in 1975 by Stan Clark and his then-partner Steve, just after they graduated college, the initial vision was simple: create a lively bar with great music and ice-cold beers. This entrepreneurial spirit, born from youthful ambition, laid the foundation for what would become one of Oklahoma’s most recognized establishments.
A pivotal moment arrived when Oklahoma’s drinking age shifted from 18 to 21, prompting a necessary evolution for the young business. Faced with changing profit margins, Stan and Steve bravely pivoted, deciding to introduce food to their menu. This strategic move marked the birth of Eskimo Joe’s as the iconic restaurant we know today. Eventually, Stan became the sole owner, guiding its growth with unwavering dedication. During my time in Stillwater, I had the distinct pleasure of meeting Stan himself and enjoying a memorable lunch at Eskimo Joe’s in his company. His insights into business, customer service, and the sheer passion required to run a successful enterprise were truly inspiring. I often wished my MBA professors possessed his practical wisdom and infectious enthusiasm. Stan’s love for Eskimo Joe’s is evident in every detail: he greeted customers warmly, knew his staff by name, and ensured our lunch was nothing short of perfect, even quickly attending to a minor spill before a photo opportunity. His commitment to excellence truly shines through in the food and the vibrant atmosphere.
When you visit, prepare to indulge in their legendary cheese fries and a classic milkshake – a combination that might not sound like the healthiest, but trust me, it’s an absolute must-try. These crispy, savory fries, generously topped with melted cheese, are so irresistibly good that you’ll want at least two plates for the table! Pair them with Joe’s classic burger, the famous fowl thing, or any other item from their diverse menu, and you’re guaranteed a delicious meal. An impressive detail is that all of Eskimo Joe’s sauces are made in-house, adding an extra layer of freshness and flavor that truly elevates their dishes.
Original Hideaway Pizza: A Slice of Oklahoma History
As a self-proclaimed pizza aficionado, I’m always on the hunt for unique and delicious slices wherever my travels take me. The Original Hideaway Pizza in Stillwater quickly captured my heart and taste buds. Holding the distinction of being the second pizza restaurant ever opened in Oklahoma, Hideaway Pizza has a rich history rooted in humble beginnings, evolving from a small local spot into a beloved Stillwater favorite. What truly sets Original Hideaway Pizza apart is its innovative approach to toppings, epitomized by their iconic “Hideaway Special.” This legendary pizza features a different topping on nearly every slice, creating a delightful surprise with each bite. I learned that the toppings for the Hideaway Special are never precisely the same, varying slightly based on who is crafting the pizza that day, making each experience uniquely wonderful.
Beyond the fantastic food, one of my absolute favorite aspects of Original Hideaway Pizza is their signature tie-dye t-shirts available for sale. These aren’t just any t-shirts; they are a testament to local craftsmanship and tradition. I discovered that one of the restaurant’s former employees still hand-dyes each and every shirt, ensuring that no two are exactly alike. This personal touch adds immense value and charm, making them truly special souvenirs. I happily picked up a beautiful purple shirt, which never fails to bring a smile to my face whenever I wear it. It’s more than just clothing; it’s a wearable piece of Stillwater’s history and creative spirit.
To complement your pizza, don’t miss out on their delicious appetizers. The fried mac and cheese and the fried mushrooms are exceptional choices. Both were so incredibly tasty that they disappeared from our table almost as soon as they arrived during our lunch. Hideaway Pizza offers a perfect blend of history, unique culinary flair, and a truly enjoyable dining experience that resonates with both locals and visitors alike.
The Rancher’s Club at The Atherton: Elevated Dining in Stillwater
While I’ll delve deeper into The Atherton Hotel in a future article, I simply must highlight its crown jewel: The Rancher’s Club. This upscale dining establishment offers a sophisticated culinary experience, making it a standout among Stillwater restaurants. It proudly holds the distinction of being one of only two restaurants in Stillwater to serve the exquisite Vegas Strip Steak – a cut of meat that was remarkably created and founded right here in Stillwater! This fact alone makes it an absolute must-try for any steak enthusiast visiting the area.
The Rancher’s Club boasts a thoughtfully curated menu, featuring a diverse array of choices designed to cater to refined palates. From perfectly cooked Filet Mignon served alongside marinated shrimp to a refreshing and flavorful grain salad, every dish is crafted with precision and presented beautifully. Prepare yourself for their legendary pecan ball dessert; it’s about four times larger than you’d expect, making it the perfect indulgent treat to share with the table, unless you possess an exceptionally hearty appetite for sweets!
One aspect I particularly appreciate about The Rancher’s Club is its accessibility to Oklahoma State University students, who can conveniently use their dining cards here. It’s widely known as a favorite spot for students to bring dates, adding a touch of elegance to their college experience without breaking the bank. Furthermore, their lunch menu presents an excellent value, offering high-quality meals at surprisingly reasonable prices. If your stay takes you to The Atherton, ensure you don’t miss their breakfast buffet. The fresh pastries alone are beyond delicious, promising a delightful start to your day. The Rancher’s Club provides a refined yet welcoming atmosphere, perfect for special occasions, business meetings, or simply enjoying a top-tier meal in Stillwater.
Granny’s Kitchen: Hometown Comfort and Quirky Charm
A visit to Stillwater simply isn’t complete without experiencing breakfast at Granny’s Kitchen. Primarily, because you absolutely have to indulge in one, or perhaps even two, of their famous cinnamon rolls – oh my, they are pure heaven! Granny’s is a true Stillwater institution, a must-visit anytime you find yourself in the vicinity. Honestly, if you’re within an hour of Stillwater and it’s anywhere near breakfast time, make a beeline for Granny’s! Their menu is not only fantastic but also delightfully hilarious. Don’t be too shy when ordering a “Nasty Granny;” it’s all part of the fun and charm that defines this beloved local spot.
And while you’ve likely already savored at least one of their legendary cinnamon rolls, trust me when I say you absolutely must order the cinnamon roll French toast as well. This decadent dish is incredibly rich and utterly worth every single calorie. It’s a masterful creation that combines two breakfast favorites into one unforgettable treat.
Beyond the incredible food, take some time to wander around the restaurant and check out their collection of t-shirts. They are SOOOOO FUNNY! I brought home two t-shirts and instantly regretted not buying a few more. On my flight home, I couldn’t stop thinking about specific designs and who they would make perfect gifts for. The next time I’m in Stillwater, Granny’s will be my go-to spot for some unique Christmas shopping.
What truly endeared me to Granny’s Kitchen was the palpable sense of warmth and genuine connection among the staff and customers. Everyone felt like family, smiling, laughing, and simply having a wonderful time. We celebrated a “birthday” at our table, and the experience was beyond fantastic! Other customers kept walking by, offering heartfelt “Happy Birthday” wishes to our celebrated guest. It was incredibly sweet and created a memorable atmosphere. If you have someone celebrating a birthday in your group, be sure to inform your waitress. The camel hat presented to the birthday person is absolutely amazing and adds to the joyful tradition!
Additional Oklahoma Travel Guides
For more adventures and insights into Oklahoma, check out these related articles:
Football 101 at OSU
Top Things to do in Stillwater
Atherton Hotel at OSU
Things to do in OKC
Oklahoma National Parks
Explore all of our comprehensive Oklahoma Travel Guides to plan your next journey!